Farming sector responds to criticism about environmental commitment

Beef and Lamb New Zealand has responded to a rural economist who controversially said the agriculture sector was not addressing its challenges and calling into question farming leadership.

The economist, Peter Fraser, said the sector needed to wake up to environmental challenges after being in a bubble under the previous government.

Beef and Lamb New Zealand general manager of policy Dave Harrison believes there is a lot of willingness in the farming sector to move forward and said farmers have an important role to play in environmental issues.

"There are things we have to begin addressing around water issues and climate change and protection of native species.

Beef and Lamb has put a lot of emphasis on placing the environment at the centre of what it does, he said.

"I don't agree there is a lack of leadership in the sector, but I do think we're maybe a little shy and a bit reticent coming forward in talking about the good things that we do.

"There is an important message here; we don't have to be perfect, but if we can accept where we are weak, and we have a plan for dealing with those weaknesses, and are open about them, I really think it is the way forward for these environmental issues."

Fish and Game New Zealand chief executive Martin Taylor said there had to be an acceptance by Federated Farmers, and all the leadership in the dairy and intensive farming sector, that changes had to be made.

The industry could not continue putting more cows on the land, using more water or intensifying production.

The time had come to "change what we are doing so we can actually go back to having rivers that are swimmable, that the water is used in the most sustainable way."

He said New Zealand can not really let it go for another five years.

Agribusiness leader Mandy Bell, niece of the late farming leader Sir Peter Elworthy, wants an independent group of farming leaders to tackle the main challenges in the sector.

Ms Bell said there was no group addressing all the challenges of water and the environment, climate change, animal welfare and health, disruptive technologies, global markets, and a changing world of food.

"We have to sit down and have a proper plan." she said. "We have got to stop being destructive in our conversations, we have to be constructive now."

[Editorial Note:  - It is disappointing that this article,does not reflect the fact that the farming leaders group made a public pledge on August 22 to work towards making New Zealand rivers swimmable. Farmers pledge to make rivers swimmable

The criticisms made by Peter Fraser, Martin Taylor and Mandy Bell may reflect their unwitting ignorance of the pledge - or be a deliberate attempt to ignore it.  

Whichever is the case, the journalist and the media outlet involved have a duty to accurately reflect the context of the latest state of this major issue rather than leaving important elements out.]